Every rider has heard it: work the bad side twice as much. Your horse is stiff tracking right, so you spend the ride on the right rein, circling and bending and flexing until he gives in. On a lot of horses that advice is incomplete. On a hypermobile horse it is often backwards.
When I put a loose-jointed horse on a circle in a clinic, the side the rider calls “good” is usually the side I’m most worried about. It feels soft because it has too much give. And the stiff side the rider has been grinding on for months is often the only side where the horse has found a way to hold himself together.
Why “Work the Bad Side” Falls Apart on This Horse
The old advice assumes the stiff side is the problem and the soft side is the goal. You loosen the tight side until it matches the easy one, and the horse ends up even.
That model works reasonably well for a horse with normal connective tissue. His crookedness comes mostly from muscle that has shortened on one side and lengthened on the other. Stretch the short side, strengthen the long side, and things even out. I wrote about that general pattern in why your horse feels stiff on the left rein, and for most horses it holds up.
The hypermobile horse is a different body. His ligaments and joint capsules give him range he can’t control with muscle. So when one side feels bendy, you have to ask a different question. Is that side supple, or is it unstable?
On these horses the soft side is usually unstable. And the stiff side is often a compensatory brace: tension the horse has recruited because his body needed something to hold onto.
What’s Actually Happening on Each Rein
The “easy” rein: too much give, not enough control
Tracking toward his loose side, the hypermobile horse bends beautifully, at least in the neck. Look closer and you’ll usually see some combination of these:
- The neck overbends from about the third vertebra forward while the ribcage stays rigid or swings outward.
- He falls out through the outside shoulder. The circle gets bigger no matter how much inside leg you use.
- The inside hind steps short or wide instead of tracking under the body.
- The contact feels light, almost too light. Riders love this. It is usually the horse avoiding the outside rein, not accepting it.
This rein feels easy because nothing pushes back. But nothing pushing back means nothing is holding the shape either. The horse is hanging out at the end of his range and letting the joints and soft tissue take the load. Over months, that is where the wear shows up.
The “stiff” rein: a brace doing a job
Tracking the other way, he feels like a plank. He leans on the inside shoulder, sets his jaw against the inside rein, and drops the circle inward. The rider’s instinct is to pull the head around, kick him off the inside leg, and keep at it until he softens.
What you are often feeling there is the horse using muscular tension to make up for passive stability he doesn’t have. He has learned that locking the base of the neck and leaning on that inside shoulder gives him a fixed point. It is not a good strategy. Still, it is a strategy, and it exists for a reason.
If you know this exact picture, where he braces through the back and leans on the inside shoulder, the “Unlocking the Back of a Stiff Horse” ride-along walks through the suppling sequence I use for it. Neutral spine walk and trot, a modest shoulder-in, leg yield, and transitions, in that order. The order matters. You are offering him a better way to stabilize before you ask him to give up the brace.
What Happens When You Drill the Stiff Side
Say you spend twenty minutes of a forty-minute ride on the stiff rein, flexing and circling and pushing him off your inside leg. Three things tend to happen.
First, you strip the brace before anything replaces it. You might win the bend for a few strides. The horse then has neither the brace nor the muscular control to do the job, so he either goes back to bracing harder or collapses somewhere else, usually through the hind end or behind the saddle.
Second, you fatigue the side that was carrying the load. That braced side has been working overtime. Asking it to do more, in a shape it can’t hold, adds load to tissue that is already stressed. On a hypermobile horse that is how you end up with the mystery “off on and off” lameness that never quite shows up on a flexion test.
Third, the loose side gets ignored. The rider spends the ride fixing the stiff rein and only visits the easy rein as a reward. So the side that actually needs stability training gets the least attention, and the attention it does get comes in the shape it already overdoes.
You end up with a horse who is just as crooked, more tired, and more anxious about the right rein than when you started.
How I Actually Work a One-Sided Hypermobile Horse
1. Rule out pain before you call it training
A strong one-sided pattern in any horse deserves a vet’s eyes. Hypermobile horses get one-sided for training reasons and for physical ones, including SI, hock, neck, feet, and saddle fit, which on these horses changes faster than most people think. Don’t spend three months on a training plan for what is really a soundness problem.
2. Give the loose side a stability goal, not a bend goal
Tracking toward the easy side, I ask for less bend than the horse offers. I keep the neck closer to straight, and the outside rein and outside leg become my main aids. Picture riding a slightly counter-flexed or straight horse on a large circle and asking him to hold the outside shoulder in place.
A useful check is to give the inside rein forward for two or three strides. If the shape falls apart the moment you stop holding it, he was never holding it himself. Keep sets short, about a quarter to half a circle of real control, then go straight.
3. Give the stiff side relief, not force
Tracking toward the braced side, I ask for very little bend at first. I want straightness and a soft jaw on a big circle or even a straight line. The brace lets go when the horse no longer needs it, not when you win the argument. Leg yield away from the inside leg on a straight line usually gets more release than any amount of flexion on a circle, because it asks him to move the shoulder without asking him to fold.
4. Change direction more often than feels normal
Long sets on either rein let the horse settle into his pattern. I change rein every few minutes, often through a straight line or a half-figure-eight. A straight stretch between directions works like a reset. It’s also where you find out whether your work on either side actually changed anything.
5. Measure evenness by quality, not by minutes
Forget equal time on each rein. What matters is equal quality of the shape. Sometimes that means more minutes on the loose side, which surprises riders who have been told the opposite for years. Sometimes a session is mostly straight lines with a few honest circles each way.
6. Build stability off the horse, too
A one-sided horse benefits from stability work he can do without a rider’s weight. The approach in the ground exercises that build proprioceptive stability applies directly here. Square halts, straight backing, and slow work on varied ground all help, and watching him in hand will often show you the asymmetry more clearly than feeling it from the saddle.
What Progress Actually Looks Like
When this starts working, the stiff side usually improves before you ask it to. The horse gets more stable on his loose side, the brace on the other side becomes less necessary, and one day he simply softens to the right rein without a fight. Riders are often shocked by that. They spent months fighting the stiff side and it came around once they quit.
Things to watch for:
- The easy rein starts to feel a little harder. That’s good. It means the outside rein and outside shoulder are now doing something.
- The circle stops drifting out on one rein and in on the other.
- The inside hind tracks more evenly in both directions.
- The contact feels more alike in both hands. Not necessarily lighter, just more alike.
Expect this to take weeks of consistent riding, not a few sessions. It is also fragile early on. If you get sloppy with the outside aids for a week, the old pattern comes back, much like a hypermobile horse’s topline disappears the moment you ride less precisely. The stability he has built depends on the precision you keep giving him.
If you want to practice the timing on your own, Sam’s ride-alongs are audio lessons you can play while you ride, so you have someone calling the changes of rein and checking your outside aids in real time. And I’ve talked through the nervous-system side of the bracing horse, why a horse holds tension he doesn’t trust himself to release, on The Elevated Equestrian podcast.
The short version is to stop treating the stiff side as the enemy. On this horse, it is usually the symptom. The cause is the side that feels too good to question.
If your horse is lovely one way and a fight the other, and drilling the bad side hasn’t changed it, I’d like to see him. In a lesson or clinic we’ll work out which side is actually unstable, find what the brace is protecting, and build a plan that gives him somewhere better to put his effort. I teach out of Aiken, SC, and travel for clinics throughout the region. Reach out through /contact to book a lesson or bring me to your barn.
