Skip to main content

Why Your Hypermobile Horse Drops Between His Shoulders First (And Why the Thoracic Sling Fails Before Anything Else)

By Samantha Baer··8 min read

Stand your hypermobile horse square on a level surface at the end of a hard week and look at him from the side. The withers sit lower between the shoulder blades than they did on Monday. There’s a little hollow just behind the scapula, and the saddle has been creeping forward all week. None of that is a coincidence, and none of it is a saddle problem.

In a loose-jointed horse, the thoracic sling is almost always the first structure to give out. It goes before the hocks, before the back gets sore, and long before anyone calls it lameness. If you understand why it fails first, you can catch it early and train it instead of chasing symptoms downstream.

The Only Place the Front End Isn’t Held Together by Bone

Horses have no collarbone. The forelimb doesn’t attach to the skeleton with a joint the way the hind limb does at the hip. Instead, the ribcage hangs between the two shoulder blades, suspended by muscle and fascia: the serratus ventralis, the pectorals, the rhomboids, the trapezius, and the connective tissue that wraps all of it.

That’s the sling. If you want the full anatomy tour, I covered it in why your hypermobile horse’s shoulders are the key to everything. For this post, one fact matters most:

The sling has no bony lock to fall back on.

The hind end has joint architecture that shares the load with soft tissue. The front end, which carries the majority of the horse’s weight before you even get on, is held up by soft tissue alone. Every stride, every landing, and every downward transition is absorbed by muscle and connective tissue. So when you have a horse whose connective tissue is built to stretch more than it should, the front end is where that weakness shows up first.

Why Hypermobility Hits the Sling Before Anything Else

In a typical horse, the passive structures (fascia, tendinous attachments, ligamentous support) do a fair share of the work of holding the trunk up. The muscles fine-tune it.

In a hypermobile horse, those passive structures give. So the muscles have to do the job the connective tissue isn’t doing, all the time, including at rest. That has three consequences:

  1. The sling muscles fatigue faster. They work harder from the first stride, so they run out of gas earlier in a session and earlier in a week.
  2. When they fatigue, there’s nothing underneath to catch the trunk. A typical horse sags a little when tired. A hypermobile horse drops, because the passive backup isn’t there.
  3. Everything behind compensates. Once the trunk sinks between the shoulders, the back hollows, the hind leg can’t push under a lifted thorax, and the horse starts pulling himself along from the front.

That last piece is why I call the sling the linchpin. Tara Osborne made the same point when she joined me on the podcast episode on balance, function, and the thoracic sling: the sling is what connects the back end to the front end. If it isn’t working, the hind end has nothing to push into, no matter how much leg you use.

What Sling Failure Looks Like Before It Looks Like Lameness

Most riders don’t notice the sling until something is already sore. These are the earlier signs I look for:

  • Withers sinking between the shoulder blades, especially after a few days of consecutive work
  • A hollow or “dip” just behind the scapula, where a stable horse would look filled in
  • The saddle migrating forward even though the fit hasn’t changed
  • Leaning on the inside shoulder on circles and through corners
  • Heaviness in the hand that gets worse as the ride goes on, not better
  • Diving into downward transitions, or losing all lift in them
  • Landing heavy and flat after fences, then running on in front
  • Girthiness or sensitivity around the pectorals that appears or worsens with workload

That collapse through transitions deserves its own conversation, and I’ve written about what’s actually collapsing when your hypermobile horse loses suspension in transitions. Short version: the transition is the moment of peak load on the sling, so it’s where a weak one shows itself.

Why More Suppleness Makes It Worse

This is where riders get stuck. The horse feels heavy and braced in front, so the instinct is to supple him: more bend, more stretching, more long-and-low to “free up” the shoulder.

On a hypermobile horse, that’s backwards. His shoulder isn’t stuck. It’s under-supported. When you stretch a horse whose passive structures already give too much, you take away the little stability he had. He’ll feel softer for ten minutes and then fall onto the forehand harder than before.

The brace you feel isn’t stiffness. It’s the horse grabbing onto anything he can, often the underneck and your hand, because the sling can’t hold him up. This is the core of why stability-first beats suppleness-first for the loose-jointed horse, and it matters most at the front end. Tara put it in Pilates terms on the podcast: these horses need stability work, not more mobility.

What to Train Instead

On the ground

Start without a rider. You want the horse to find the lift himself before you ask him to hold it under weight.

  • Thoracic sling lifts. Use light pressure or a scratch at the sternum between the front legs to ask the horse to lift the base of his withers up between his shoulder blades. You’re looking for a small, real lift. Hold a breath or two, release, repeat a few times. Don’t hold it until he quivers. Quality over duration.
  • Slow walk over poles. Walk only, at first. Poles ask the front end to pick up and place each foot, which recruits the sling instead of letting the horse fall from one front leg to the other.
  • Incline work. Walking up a gentle hill makes the hind end push and the front end lift. Keep it slow enough that he can’t scramble.
  • Podiums and balance pads. Tara includes these in her toolkit, and the principle is sound. Small, controlled weight-shifting challenges make the stabilizers fire without big ranges of motion.

Under saddle

Your job in the saddle is to give the sling a stable frame to work inside, not to create bend.

  • Neutral spine first. Ride walk and trot with the neck neither jammed up nor dropped to the ground, so the horse can actually lift the base of the neck.
  • Small-angle shoulder-in. Think three tracks at most, often less. You want the inside hind stepping under a lifted shoulder, not a dramatic angle that lets the outside shoulder bulge.
  • Leg yield to straighten, not to bend. On a horse who leans in, a few steps of leg yield out picks the inside shoulder back up.
  • Transitions within the gait. Shorten and lengthen the trot over three or four strides rather than doing big gait changes, so the sling learns to carry through changes in load.

If your horse leans on the inside shoulder and braces against you through the warmup, that’s the sling asking for help. The “Unlocking the Back of a Stiff Horse” ride-along walks through this exact sequence in 16 minutes: neutral spine walk and trot, shoulder-in, leg yield, and transitions, with cues in your ear in real time.

The Landing Problem for Jumping Horses

Jumping makes all of this matter more. As Tara explained, when horses land from fences there’s a disengagement of the thoracic sling. Every landing is a moment where the front end absorbs the full force of the trunk coming down, and in a hypermobile horse there’s less passive tissue to soften that.

Her recommendation is one I agree with completely: after a competition, don’t just carry on with the season. Put a few sessions of groundwork in, sling lifts included, to bring the horse back to where he was before the weekend. In her framing, sport is always a compromise, but the trade-off can’t be the horse’s body. A hypermobile eventer can’t afford to bank fatigue in the sling and hope it sorts itself out over the winter.

The Bottom Line

The thoracic sling fails first in the hypermobile horse because it’s the one place where the front end is held up entirely by soft tissue, and soft tissue is exactly what’s compromised. When it goes, the back, the hind end, and eventually soundness follow.

So watch the withers. Watch where the saddle ends up. Feel whether the horse gets heavier or lighter as the ride goes on. Then stop trying to stretch him loose and start teaching him to hold himself up. If you want structure for practicing on your own, Sam’s ride-alongs give you audio lessons you can play while you ride.


If you want eyes on your horse’s front end, I work on this in clinics and lessons. We’ll look at how he stands, how he lands, and how he carries through transitions, and then build a plan that stabilizes the sling instead of stretching it. Reach out at /contact to get on the calendar.

The ideas in this post are part of a bigger framework for training the hypermobile horse, and I’m putting the whole thing into my book. Join the waitlist to be first in line when it’s ready.

Reading about it is step one.

Want me in your ear while you actually ride it? Ride Along is my library of audio lessons you play in the saddle — real coaching, every ride.

Explore the Lesson Library →

Or start with two free lessons.

Samantha Baer

About Samantha Baer

Samantha is a professional eventing rider, trainer, and host of The Elevated Equestrian podcast. She believes in training horses with science, empathy, and patience.

Enjoyed this post?

Get new articles delivered to your inbox every week.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime.