Skip to main content

The Training Plateau: Why It Happens and What It Actually Means

By Samantha Baer···7 min read

If you’ve been riding for any length of time, you’ve felt it. That moment when everything seems to stall. The progress you were making? Gone. The improvements you could see? Invisible now. You’re showing up, putting in the work, and somehow getting… nowhere. Your horse still falls in on the same circle. The canter lead you’ve been drilling for weeks? Still scrambled.

Welcome to the training plateau. And before you spiral into “maybe I’m just not talented enough” territory, let me stop you right there.

The plateau isn’t a sign you’re failing. It’s a sign you’re about to level up.

Why Plateaus Are Actually Part of the Process

Here’s the thing nobody tells you: skill acquisition isn’t linear. It doesn’t move in a nice steady upward line. It looks more like stairs — periods of rapid improvement followed by flat stretches where nothing seems to change.

Those flat stretches? They’re not wasted time. Your brain and your body are consolidating what you’ve learned. You’re building the foundation for the next jump.

Think about learning a new movement with your horse — say, shoulder-in. At first, you’re consciously thinking about every aid. Outside leg back, inside leg at the girth, half-halt, keep the bend, don’t let the haunches swing… It’s a lot. And it’s clunky.

Then one day, you just do it. The movement becomes integrated. Your body knows what to do without you having to micromanage every detail.

But between “consciously thinking about every step” and “it’s second nature” is a whole lot of plateau. That’s where the magic happens — you just can’t see it while you’re in it.

The Real Reasons You’re Stuck

While some plateaus are just part of learning, others happen because something actually needs to change. Here are the most common culprits:

1. You’re doing the same thing expecting different results

If you’ve been schooling the same exercises the same way for months, your horse has adapted. Adaptation isn’t progress — it’s maintenance. Your body has also adapted. You’re not building new neural pathways; you’re just reinforcing old ones.

The fix: Change something. A different exercise. A different order. Work on a foundational skill you’ve been neglecting. Sometimes the breakthrough comes from going backward before you can go forward.

2. You’re overthinking

I see this constantly. Riders who are so in their heads about doing everything “right” that they stop actually riding. They’re mentally narrating every stride, critiquing every transition, tensing up at every imperfection.

Your horse feels that. And now you’re both stuck.

The fix: Give yourself permission to ride badly for one session. Seriously. Just move with your horse. Feel instead of think. Often the plateau breaks when you stop trying so hard.

3. There’s a physical limitation in the way

Sometimes the plateau isn’t about training — it’s about bodies. Your horse might be compensating for discomfort you can’t see. You might have asymmetries in your own body that are blocking your aids.

The fix: Get eyes on the ground. A good instructor, a bodywork professional for your horse, even video of yourself riding. Sometimes the thing holding you back is invisible to you but obvious to someone else.

4. You’ve outgrown your current approach

What got you here won’t get you there. The exercises that worked when you were building basics don’t work when you’re refining feel. The cues that made sense for a green horse don’t make sense for a made one.

The fix: Be honest about where you actually are and what you actually need. Sometimes progress requires a new program, a different perspective, or a commitment to work you’ve been avoiding.

How Long Do Plateaus Last?

The frustrating answer: it depends.

Some plateaus are weeks. Some are months. I’ve had plateaus that lasted over a year. The length often depends on how willing you are to do something different — and how patient you can be while your nervous system catches up to your ambitions.

The good news? Plateaus do end. Usually suddenly. You’ll be trudging along, feeling like nothing’s changing, and then one day everything clicks. The feeling you’ve been chasing just shows up. The movement that felt impossible becomes easy.

That’s the reward for sticking with it through the flat parts.

And while you’re waiting for that click, zoom out. Think back to where you were six months ago. A year ago. Most of the time you’ll find progress you couldn’t see in the daily grind. The canter that used to be terrifying is now just frustrating. The bend that never existed is now inconsistent instead of absent. That’s not nothing. That’s growth — give yourself credit for it.

What to Do When You’re In It

First: recognize it. Half the battle is knowing that what you’re experiencing is normal and temporary.

Next: get curious, not critical. When you’re stuck, your brain wants someone to blame. Your horse is lazy. Your coach doesn’t get it. You’re a bad rider. None of that helps. Instead, ask yourself — without judgment:

  • What specifically feels off right now?
  • Is this a new issue, or something that’s been lurking for a while?
  • Am I asking clearly, or is there confusion in my aids?
  • Could my horse be uncomfortable somewhere?

Write the answers down. Putting words to that vague “nothing’s working” feeling often turns up something specific you can actually fix.

Then:

  1. Change one variable. Not everything — just one thing. A new exercise. A different warm-up. Working on something adjacent to what you’ve been drilling. Simplify your goals for the ride. Add longer walk breaks. Go back to an exercise that used to feel good. Let your horse stretch and move freely for a few minutes before you ask for anything technical. And resist the urge to overhaul everything at once — new saddle, new bit, new coach, new horse. If you change ten things, you’ll never know which one helped.

  2. Get feedback. Fresh eyes catch what you’ve gone blind to. A lesson, a clinic, even a friend with a good eye. If you have a coach, really talk to them. They can see your riding, but they can’t see inside your head. Tell them you’re feeling stuck. Ask what they’re seeing from the ground, and what you should be prioritizing that you might be missing.

  3. Commit to a timeframe. One of the most powerful things you can do is decide: “For the next 28 days, I’m going to focus specifically on X.” A timeframe that’s long enough to see real change but short enough to feel achievable.

  4. Trust the process. I know, I know. But really — this is where most people quit. Right before the breakthrough. Don’t be that person.

And on the days when even that feels like too much, remember why you ride. Go on a trail ride. Hand-graze your horse. Sit in the pasture and just watch them exist. You don’t have to achieve something every single ride. Sometimes just being with your horse is enough.

The Plateau Is a Teacher

When you’re in the thick of it, plateaus feel like punishment. But they’re actually information. They’re showing you where the edges of your current abilities are. They’re inviting you to grow.

Every rider I respect has stories about the plateau that almost broke them. And they’re still riding because they pushed through it anyway.

So if you’re stuck right now — good. That means you’re at the edge of something new. Keep going.


Feeling like your horse’s stiffness is part of what’s holding you back? Tap the horse you have today in my Ride Along library and press play — no more guessing what to do next.

Reading about it is step one.

Want me in your ear while you actually ride it? Ride Along is my library of audio lessons you play in the saddle — real coaching, every ride.

Explore the Lesson Library →

Or start with two free lessons.

Samantha Baer

About Samantha Baer

Samantha is a professional eventing rider, trainer, and host of The Elevated Equestrian podcast. She believes in training horses with science, empathy, and patience.

Enjoyed this post?

Get new articles delivered to your inbox every week.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime.