Skip to main content

Ogilvy Sheepskin vs. Memory Foam Half Pad: Splurge or Save? Holiday Buying Guide (2026)

By Samantha Baer··9 min read

Every November I get the same message: “I have one big tack purchase in me this year. Is the sheepskin pad worth it, or should I just get the memory foam?” It’s a fair question. The two Ogilvy pads share the same memory foam core, but their starting prices are about $253 apart. That gap is either the smartest money you spend on your horse’s back this year or a very expensive way to feel good about your tack trunk. Which one it is depends on your horse, not the holiday calendar.

This post contains affiliate links. If you shop through them I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you — and you’ll get my reader discount. I only feature gear I’d actually put on my own horses or wear for a full day in the saddle.

One thing up front. Ogilvy hasn’t announced a Black Friday sale, and I’m not going to guess at one. This post is about which pad earns its price. The only discount I can promise is my reader code. If a sale does show up later, you’ll already know which pad belongs in your cart.


The Quick Comparison

Pad Starting price Best for Skip it if
Classic Jump Memory Foam Half Pad from $195 Even pressure distribution, daily work, tight saddle fits Your horse is skin-sensitive or rub-prone
Classic Dressage Memory Foam Half Pad from $195 Same, in a dressage cut Same
Classic Jump Sheepskin Memory Foam Half Pad from $448 Sensitive backs, heavy sweaters, riders buying one pad for years Your saddle fit is already snug, or you won’t keep up with sheepskin care
Classic Dressage Sheepskin Memory Foam Half Pad from $448 Same, in a dressage cut Same

Pick the cut to match your saddle, not the discipline you mostly ride. If you ride in an all-purpose or close-contact saddle, go jump.


The Save Pick: Ogilvy Memory Foam Half Pad

The Classic Jump Memory Foam Half Pad and the Classic Dressage Memory Foam Half Pad both start at $195. They are the workhorse of the Ogilvy range for one reason: pressure distribution. The memory foam pockets spread the load of saddle and rider across the back, so you don’t get the concentrated pressure points that show up as dry spots, a tight back in the warm-up, or a horse who sinks away from the girth.

It’s also the thinner of the two pads. People underrate that. Plenty of saddles fit well but don’t have much room to spare under the panels. A thinner half pad lets you add cushion without changing how the saddle sits. If your fitter has ever told you “don’t add bulk,” this is the pad you can usually use anyway. Still, put it under your saddle and check your fit before you ride in it.

Who it’s for:

  • Horses with a reasonable saddle fit who need the load spread more evenly. Think of the horse who is a little sore after long schooling sessions, or the one whose sweat pattern is patchy.
  • Horses with no particular skin sensitivity, where the job is distributing pressure and nothing more.
  • Riders with snug saddle fits who can’t afford to add thickness.
  • Riders who want a second pad in rotation so one can be in the wash.

Who it’s not for:

  • Horses who need correction rather than cushion. If your saddle tips, drops at the pommel, or slides to one side, memory foam won’t level it. That’s a job for the Classic Jump Shimmable Half Pad ($360) and inserts.
  • Horses who rub, gall, or get reactive at the skin. The memory foam pad handles pressure. It doesn’t handle what happens where the pad meets the coat.

If you’d rather design your own, the USA Custom Memory Foam Half Pad in jump and dressage cuts starts at $141.40. That’s a base price, and each customization adds to it. Don’t treat it as a cheaper version of the Classic pad. It’s a build-your-own option, and the Classic is the finished, ready-to-ship one.

My honest take: the Memory Foam Half Pad is the right answer for the majority of horses. A “save” pick here isn’t a compromise. It’s what most backs actually need.


The Splurge Pick: Ogilvy Sheepskin Memory Foam Half Pad

The Classic Jump Sheepskin Memory Foam Half Pad and the Classic Dressage Sheepskin Memory Foam Half Pad start at $448. You get the same memory foam pressure distribution with a sheepskin layer added. That layer is what you’re paying for, so be clear on what it does.

Sheepskin handles the surface. It wicks moisture away from the coat and breathes. It also cuts friction between pad and horse in a way synthetic tops don’t. For a horse whose problem sits at the skin as much as in the muscle, that matters. This is the horse who comes out of the tack with rubbed hair, a hot, damp patch that takes forever to dry, or a flinch when you run a hand down his back.

I covered the heat side of this in sheepskin vs. memory foam half pads in summer heat. November changes the math. Your horse is growing in a winter coat, or he’s freshly clipped and his skin is suddenly exposed. Either way, sweat behaves differently. A thick coat holds moisture against the back after work. A clipped back loses the coat that was buffering friction. Sheepskin helps in both cases. The warmth that’s a mild liability in July is an asset on a 38-degree morning.

Who it’s for:

  • Horses who are sensitive at the skin: rub-prone, quick to show pressure marks, or reactive to synthetic fabrics.
  • Heavy sweaters, especially fuzzy ones whose backs stay damp long after the ride.
  • Older horses or horses with a history of back soreness, where you want every comfort layer working for you.
  • Riders buying one pad they intend to use for several seasons, not one of many in rotation.

Who it’s not for:

  • Horses whose saddle fit is already tight. Sheepskin is another layer. If the channel or the panels are snug, test the fit carefully before you commit, or stay with the thinner Memory Foam pad.
  • Riders who won’t keep up with the care. Sheepskin takes more careful washing and a lot longer to dry than a synthetic pad. Follow Ogilvy’s care instructions on the product page. If your laundry routine is “throw it in with the saddle pads,” you’ll ruin a $448 pad.
  • Horses who need correction. Same rule as above: this pad cushions, it doesn’t shim.

A USA Custom Sheepskin Memory Foam Half Pad also exists in jump and dressage cuts, starting at $318.50 before customizations, which add to the price. Choose it if you want to design the pad yourself, not as a way around the Classic price.


Ready to try the Ogilvy Sheepskin Memory Foam Half Pad? Use my link with code SAMANTHABAER10 for 10% at Ogilvy Equestrian → https://ogilvyequestrian.com/samanthabaer


How I’d Decide (and What I’d Grab If a Sale Comes)

Here’s the decision the way I’d walk a client through it.

Answer the correction question first. Before you choose between these two, make sure cushion is actually the problem. If the saddle doesn’t sit level, neither pad fixes it, and you’d be better off putting that money toward a shimmable pad and inserts. If you’re not sure which problem you have, my buying guide to the Baby Pad, Profile Pad and half pads sorts that out before you spend anything.

Then look at the skin, not the muscle. If your horse’s back is fine at the surface and you just want better pressure distribution, buy the Memory Foam Half Pad and don’t second-guess it. If you’re seeing rubs, slow-drying sweat, or surface sensitivity, the sheepskin is the pad that addresses what you’re actually seeing. In that case the extra cost buys you something real.

Factor in how long you’ll own it. The splurge makes sense when you’re buying one pad to live on one horse for years. Spread over a few seasons of daily rides, the cost difference shrinks fast. If you swap horses often, lease, or want multiple pads in rotation, two Memory Foam pads will serve you better than one sheepskin.

Check fit with the pad in place. Whichever you buy, set it under your saddle, girth up, and look before you ride. The pad should sit under the panels without bunching or creeping past the edges. If the saddle suddenly feels perched or tight through the channel, the pad is too much for that fit. With the sheepskin, that’s the most common reason to send it back.

Don’t skip the baby pad. Run a thin, sweat-wicking layer underneath: the Classic Jump Baby Pad ($109) or the Classic Dressage Baby Pad ($120). With a sheepskin half pad this matters even more. You wash the baby pad after every ride and the sheepskin far less often, which is how it lasts.

If a sale does come: I’d use it as the moment to buy the splurge pad, not to buy more pads. The Memory Foam Half Pad is a sensible full-price buy any month of the year. The sheepskin is the purchase people put off, so if it’s the right pad for your horse, that’s the one to grab.

I’ve talked through how pressure and friction show up differently in a horse’s back, and why riders mix them up, on the podcast. If you’re still on the fence, that conversation will help.


The short version: most horses need the Memory Foam Half Pad, and buying it is a smart decision, not settling. The Sheepskin Memory Foam Half Pad earns its price on the horse who is sensitive at the skin, sweats heavily under a fall coat or a fresh clip, and will wear the same pad for years. If that’s your horse, the splurge is worth it. If it isn’t, save the $253, buy the memory foam, and put the difference toward a good baby pad and your next saddle fitter visit.

Ready to try the Ogilvy Memory Foam or Sheepskin Memory Foam Half Pad? Use my link with code SAMANTHABAER10 for 10% at Ogilvy Equestrian → https://ogilvyequestrian.com/samanthabaer

Reading about it is step one.

Want me in your ear while you actually ride it? Ride Along is my library of audio lessons you play in the saddle — real coaching, every ride.

Explore the Lesson Library →

Or start with two free lessons.

Samantha Baer

About Samantha Baer

Samantha is a professional eventing rider, trainer, and host of The Elevated Equestrian podcast. She believes in training horses with science, empathy, and patience.

Enjoyed this post?

Get new articles delivered to your inbox every week.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime.