Skip to main content

How to Build Jumping Confidence Without Raising the Fences (And Why 'Just Go Bigger' Keeps Backfiring)

By Samantha Baer··8 min read

One of the fastest ways to make a nervous jumper more nervous is to put the fence up. Riders do it all the time, usually with good intentions: you jumped 2’3” well last week, so this week the cups go up a hole. Then the approach feels longer, your shoulders creep forward, your horse feels it, and suddenly you’re less confident at 2’6” than you were at 2’3”.

The problem isn’t you. The problem is that height is the only variable most riders know how to change.

Height Is the Laziest Variable in Jumping

Height is easy to measure, so it becomes the scoreboard. But for most riders, fear over fences has very little to do with the six inches between one hole and the next.

When I ask riders what actually scares them, the answers are almost never “the jump is tall.” They sound like this:

  • “I don’t know if I’m going to see a distance.”
  • “He gets quick in the last three strides and I can’t get him back.”
  • “I’m fine until the turn after.”
  • “I’m scared of the landing.”

None of those problems get solved by a bigger fence. They get louder at a bigger fence. Raising the rails before you’ve solved them is just raising the stakes on a question you can’t answer yet.

What Confidence Actually Is Over Fences

Your nervous system relaxes when it can predict what happens next. Confidence over fences is the accumulated evidence that you can handle what comes up: a long spot, a wiggle in the line, a horse who looks at a filler. Every rep of “that wasn’t perfect, I adjusted, and it was fine” teaches your body that the unexpected is survivable.

That’s why I keep saying confidence isn’t the absence of fear, it’s a shorter recovery time. You build that recovery time through volume of manageable surprises, not one big scary one.

Raising the height before you have that evidence is flooding. You might get over it, but your nervous system files the experience under “barely survived,” not “handled it.” It’s the same reason pushing through the fear is the worst advice anyone ever gave a rider. You’re training your body to expect danger at the exact moment you want it to feel capable.

The Variables That Build Confidence (All at Low Height)

Keep the fences at a height that bores you. Then change one of these at a time.

1. Rhythm before anything else

Put a single ground pole on a 20-meter circle. Canter it ten times in a row and count out loud: “one, two, one, two.” Your job is not to find a distance. It’s to keep the same canter whether the pole comes up long, short, or perfect.

Most riders who “can’t see a distance” actually can’t hold a rhythm. Fix the rhythm and the distances start showing up on their own.

2. Turns and track

Same 2’ vertical, different approach. Come off a short turn. Come off a long, straight approach. Jump it on a slight angle. Put it in the middle of the arena, off the rail, where there’s nothing to lean on.

Every new approach is a new question at zero added risk. If a short turn makes your stomach drop, you’ve just found the actual work, and it has nothing to do with height.

3. Bad distances on purpose

Pull the placing pole out and ride a crossrail without trying to fix anything. Let it come up long. Let it come up deep. Notice that you stayed on, your horse jumped, and the world kept going.

A chip at 2’ is a learning experience. A chip at 3’ with no prior reps is a confidence crisis. Collect your bad distances while they’re cheap.

4. New looks, same size

Change what the fence looks like before you change how big it is. A flower box under a pole. A tarp folded on the ground. A barrel on its side. Two standards that are a different color.

This builds confidence for both of you. Your horse learns that new things are just new things, and you learn to ride forward to a question without the rails going up at the same time.

5. Gymnastics that do the riding for you

A simple grid lets you practice your position without managing the approach. Something like a trot pole roughly 8 to 9 feet to a small crossrail, then about 18 feet to a small vertical for one canter stride. Adjust for your horse’s stride, and keep everything small.

Use the grid to practice one thing at a time: eyes up, an exhale over the crossrail, a soft release. If your hands get yanked around every time your horse lands, that’s a body-control issue more than a nerve issue, and these off-horse drills for independent hands will do more for you than another jumping lesson.

6. Landing and riding away

A lot of fear lives on the back side of the fence. Practice landing and then doing something deliberate: land and halt straight, land and trot, land and turn left on purpose.

When the landing has a plan, your brain stops treating the moment after the fence as a free fall.

When the Horse Is the One Who’s Worried

Sometimes the rider is fine and the horse is the one rushing, bidding for the fence, or jumping like it’s an emergency. More height won’t fix that either.

Eventer and show jumper Adele Shaw said something on the podcast that reframes this. With young and green horses, she teaches them early that stopping is an option. Owners watching are usually horrified. But she found that when off-the-track Thoroughbreds who bid hard at fences learned they didn’t have to go over, the rushing eased and their confidence went up. Her read was that the rushing came from worry, either about not being able to do it or about what happens if they don’t. Take the pressure off the question, and the horse can actually think about the answer.

You don’t have to adopt her whole method to take the lesson. A rushing horse is often an anxious horse, and you don’t fix anxiety with a bigger bit or a bigger fence.

The rushing also usually starts long before the jump. If your horse scoots away from your leg in the warm-up, he’ll scoot away from your leg in the last three strides. That’s exactly what the “Hot Horse Warm-Up” ride-along walks through: shoulder-in at the walk, leg yields, half-halts that actually land, and posting into the canter so a sensitive horse can’t jolt away from you. Get that conversation working on the flat, and the approach to a fence stops being a negotiation.

A Simple Low-Fence Session

Here’s what a confidence-building session can look like with nothing over 2’:

  1. Flatwork that gets your horse listening to your leg without running from it.
  2. Ground pole on a circle: ten repetitions, counting the rhythm out loud.
  3. Small grid: three or four passes, one position focus each time.
  4. Single vertical, three approaches: long straight, short turn, slight angle.
  5. Add a filler or a new look to the same vertical.
  6. Land and halt after every fence in the last round.
  7. Quit on a good one. Not the best one possible. A good one.

That’s a full workout for both of you, and the rails never went up.

So When Do You Go Up?

When the current height is genuinely boring. I mean you can ride it off any turn, out of any distance, with a new filler underneath, and still breathe. “I survived it” is not the bar. “I could do this half asleep” is the bar.

Then raise it one hole and simplify everything else. Straight approach, familiar fence, no fillers. Once that’s boring too, start layering the other variables back in. And when a rough day comes, drop the height without guilt. Going back down is not regression. It’s how you keep your nervous system’s evidence file full of wins.

You can do a lot of the flat foundation on your own. The ride-along library has audio lessons you can play while you ride, so the rhythm and leg work are solid before you ever point at a fence.

Want Help Finding Your Real Variable?

Most riders already know their height. What they don’t know is which variable is actually shaking their confidence: the turn, the rhythm, the landing, or a horse who’s worried in his own right. That’s much easier to spot from the ground.

If you’d like to sort it out with me in person, book a clinic or lesson here. And if you’re on the fence about a clinic, here’s what riders actually experience at a confidence-building clinic, so you know what you’re signing up for. Bring your horse and your nerves. We’ll keep the fences small and make the questions better.

Reading about it is step one.

Want me in your ear while you actually ride it? Ride Along is my library of audio lessons you play in the saddle — real coaching, every ride.

Explore the Lesson Library →

Or start with two free lessons.

Samantha Baer

About Samantha Baer

Samantha is a professional eventing rider, trainer, and host of The Elevated Equestrian podcast. She believes in training horses with science, empathy, and patience.

Enjoyed this post?

Get new articles delivered to your inbox every week.

No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime.